Tried and found guilty on a charge of public immorality, the Viennese听artist Egon Schiele (1890鈥�1918) served a twenty-four-day prison sentence in April 1912. The initial charge, the kidnap and rape of the teenager Tatjana von Mossig, had been dropped, but in the process of investigating it the police had raided his studio and confiscated a series of erotic works, deemed pornographic.1听The drawings, watercolours and gouaches, as well as other nudes from the period 1910鈥�1912, have caused much debate ever since. Alessandra Comini is correct in saying that we must turn to the intellectual and cultural climate of Schiele鈥檚 Vienna to understand these images. However, her statement, 鈥榯he elusive element that this Expressionist artist sought in his portraiture accurately mirrors the collective cultural quest of his time: the inner self 鈥� psychological man鈥� should be further nuanced to differentiate Schiele鈥檚 works from the fundamental Freudian definition of 鈥榩sychological鈥�.2
Broken down etymologically, psychology is the study of the soul or spirit, from the Greek 鈥樝埾呄囄� (psych铆)鈥�. It is here that the first problem is encountered in much Schiele scholarship. There is a tendency to look for the 鈥榮oul鈥� of the artist in the images he created, to read into the mottled flesh of his self-portraits the history of a syphilitic father, to perceive his 鈥榠mmorality鈥� in a woman鈥檚 splayed legs, or to uncover traces of his mother鈥檚 sorrow at her many stillbirths in the distorted figures of children. This article argues that this channel of enquiry so often taken by Schiele scholars is problematic. Can paint really contain the 鈥榮oul鈥� of the artist? Instead, I propose to take on W. J. T. Mitchell鈥檚 recent (1996) challenge and use Schiele鈥檚 nudes as the basis for a 鈥榯hought experiment鈥�, questioning the idea of desire that is offered up by the images themselves, asking 鈥榳hat do听迟丑别测听really want?鈥�.3听In this endeavour, I would ask the reader for Mitchell鈥檚 suspension of disbelief.
The nudes of the period 1910 to 1912 like听Seated Male Nude听(Fig. 1, 1910) or听Black-Haired Nude Girl Standing听(Fig. 2, 1910), distinguished by their bold, pared-back linearity, appear to stand outside the model of the psyche created by Sigmund Freud, typically characterised by repression. These images allow, and often foreground sexual desire. Mitchell postulated an idea of images whose wants could be as numerous as the works they emanated from, though often they can be perceived as a lack.4听In the first part of this article, I would like to suggest that Schiele鈥檚 early nudes wish to capture the viewer through the visuality of sexual enjoyment and fulfilment. Viewed from this perspective, it becomes clear that Schiele鈥檚 works cannot be simply explained through use of Freudian theory.
However, turn-of-the-century Vienna was not a place in which the surface of society (or the surface of the paper) was intended to show such an unbridled social existence. It was supposed to be 鈥榓 faultless, radiant fa莽ade鈥�, yet behind the mirage of political and social stability flowed currents of prostitution, poverty, crime and social unrest.5听Though the ruling classes might have wished to continue believing in the strength of the old Hapsburg regime, these undercurrents were fracturing the Austro-Hungarian Empire long before the First World War sealed its fate. By ignoring the convention of the facade, Schiele鈥檚 images are aligned with alternative currents of thought of the day, Freud鈥檚 thought included, that were breaking ties with the outlook of the nineteenth century, and the perceived civic failure with which this was connected. Reacting to his environment, Freud aimed to provide what he considered to be the foundation for an a-historical view of the psyche removed from concepts of class and societal norms.6听In this way, Schiele鈥檚 images are connected to Freud more subtly than the later twentieth- and twenty-first-century application of psychoanalytic theory to the works makes clear. These figures deny society鈥檚 hold over them by appearing in a void. Stepping beyond this boundary,听Seated Male Nude听seems to reject not only society but also the very laws of science. The chair 鈥� a societal prop 鈥� having been removed, he is supported by and suspended in emptiness.
Challenging Mitchell鈥檚 hypothesis that images are not reducible to language, especially in light of their own desires, this article then considers Schiele鈥檚 nudes in relation to a different channel of Viennese thought: the turn-of-the-century听厂辫谤补肠丑办谤颈蝉别听(language crisis) and, ultimately, Ludwig Wittgenstein鈥檚听Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus,听first conceived of in 1913. In this seminal text Wittgenstein was grappling with the idea of how to make the nature of our thoughts clear. In a comparably perilous act, Schiele鈥檚 images seem to be trying to find a way to express clear or overt sexuality. Similar to Wittgenstein鈥檚 deconstruction of language into component cells, the sparse, linear figure that the nudes of 1910-1912 offer up is broken down into geometric blocks of flesh, where sexuality becomes a tangible component. 滨苍听Female Nude听(Fig. 3, 1910) the truncated figure is constructed of delineated shapes and sharp brushstrokes. The hexagonal face rests in a halo of broad purple, red and pink lines, the circle of the stomach is cupped in pink highlighting and divided in two, balanced precariously on a triangle of dark pubic hair. There is no attempt to fully integrate the various parts of the body. Instead, the thick white outline both highlights the angular collection of parts and prevents them from falling apart on the page.
The figure seems to exhibit no inhibition, the image bares itself fully to the viewer. The purple of her stocking tops mimics the triangle of the vagina, creating a听尘颈蝉别-别苍-补产卯尘别听of sexuality.7听This is a productive example of Mitchell鈥檚 suggestion that an image can want mastery over the beholder, that it might desire to change places with him or her, holding the viewer still in what he terms 鈥榯he Medusa effect鈥�.8听The onlooker鈥檚 gaze is trapped by the image between its purple stockings and its red-purple halo of wild, almost snake-like hair. In Freud鈥檚 writings the Ego (or the conscious) is responsible for the processing of perceptions and excitations coming from the exter颅nal world.9听It is here that the balance between听辫濒别补蝉耻谤别听补苍诲听un辫濒别补蝉耻谤别听is regulated through the repression of certain excitations deemed too strong for the maintenance of the mental equilibrium. The Ego acts as the border between internal and external perceptions, both of which leave traces that become memory in the unconscious.10听The Id exists in two forms: the latent thought that can become conscious without aid and the repressed thought that can only become conscious through the aid of psychoanalysis.11听All repression stems from the socially aware Ego, developed through the repression of infantile sexuality, originally overt and free, which is incompatible with social reality.12
It is clear from his writings that Schiele was aware of the fluidity of Freudian boundaries within himself and within his reactions to the world around him. In his prison diary he wrote:
Have adults forgotten how corrupted they themselves were as chil颅dren 鈥� that is, how incited and aroused they were by the promptings of sex? And, while they were still children, what terrible passion burned within them and tormented them? I have not forgotten, for I suffered dreadfully from it.13
Schiele acknowledges a certain 鈥榰n-repression鈥� in himself. In the same way, his nudes offer the viewer images of their bodies freed from the binding social conventions that forbade open displays of sexuality.
Let us consider听Male Nude Seated听in this way. A number of stud颅ies see Schiele鈥檚 use of truncation of the limbs in his portraits as a sign of the artist suffering from a castration complex.14听However, if we ask what the 鈥榥ude man鈥� wants, then this fear of dismemberment is challenged by the placement of the truncated limbs. The viewer鈥檚 gaze is led from the pungent pubic hair and the genital area along the legs, which become an extension and multiplication of the sexual self: rather than being a sign of castration, they mimic the shape of the phallus. The transformation of the limb into an object with sexual potential shifts the socially accept颅able status of the leg into the habitually socially-repressed sexual realm. This energy extends along the thighs towards the space of the external gaze, as though the figure is inviting the viewer to enter the visual field and indulge in similar freedoms. When viewed from this perspective Schiele鈥檚 charge of public indecency seems more complex. He had let loose in the world a multitude of characters who all had the power to invite supposedly respectable citizens to join them in unrepressed and unbounded expressions of desire. As the artist he might be charged with aiding and abetting, but was he the perpetrator?
Rather than try to read Schiele鈥檚 desires into this watercolour, it is more worthwhile to consider how Freudian theory can illuminate this visuality of desire. 滨苍听Beyond the Pleasure Principle听(1920) Freud proposes that all humans share an inherent instinct that urges them to return to an earlier state of things, the initial state of being, before life. Thus, the repressed aim of all life is death 鈥� the death drive or 鈥楾hanatos鈥� drive. The drives that do not seek to restore an earlier state are the pleasure drives or 鈥楨ros鈥� drives; these seek the sexual satisfaction of听jouissance, though they can be sublimated to find satisfaction in non-sexual achievement. They are the constructive instincts that balance the destructive instinct of Thanatos.15
滨苍听Male Nude Seated听the use of clear geometric shapes holds the gaze at the genitals, caught in the abdominal circle, then draws the eye up the body through the triangle of the ribcage to the more prominent triangle created by the red of the nipples and the eye, where the viewer comes to rest. Perhaps we can think of this as a movement beyond the Freudian pleasure principle into a state of unbalance usually modified by the repression of excess excitation.16听This is a visual encoding of the state of听unpleasure. According to Freud, the divided human psyche would attempt to repress this, but the figure鈥檚 arms embrace the sensa颅tion. Society found Schiele鈥檚 figures so difficult to accept because they showed what a place beyond the social 鈥榩leasure principle鈥� might look like. What Freud called the psychological and explored through language, Schiele made visual 鈥� in his works the study of the illusive 鈥榩syche鈥� could be replaced with the study of the body and its desires.
Historically, feminist art history has considered the nude repre颅sentation of women as passive objects of the male gaze.17听That could be one way of reading听Black Haired Girl with Raised Skirt听(Fig. 4, 1911), in which the figure freely offers up her body to the viewer. However, situated within Schiele鈥檚 wider oeuvre, perhaps we can com颅plicate conventional assumptions about the gendered gaze. For instance,听贰谤辞蝉听(Fig. 5, 1911) foregrounds male nudity and sexuality as the object of the spectator 鈥� the grey cloak framing the bright orange and red of the penis in the same way as the girl鈥檚 blue-black skirt frames the bright pink of her vagina. It remains unclear whether the artist envisaged a gendered gaze in this situation. I would argue that the ambivalence in his work surrounding the issue problematises the traditional western gendering of representation in feminist discourse. Schiele represents an unbounded sexual openness belonging equally to men and women.
Returning to the subject at hand, what exactly do we mean by making desire visual? Nudity was not a new concept in art. Botticelli鈥檚听The Birth of Venus听(1484鈥�1486) rising from the waves is naked, Titian鈥檚听Venus of Urbino听(1538) naked, Goya鈥檚听Maya Desnuda听(1797鈥�1800) had her clothes ripped from her body. However, in all these instances the figures in the images still block the vagina from the penetrating gaze of the beholder, either with their hands or their thighs.听The Black Haired Girl听with Raised Skirt听in contrast sheds any means by which this might be denied to the viewer. Her hands disappear into the emptiness of the paper, and her skirt frames her vagina, mirroring the blue-black aureole of hair around her face. The equation of the two is further highlighted by the use of rose pink to pick out the lips and the labia. However, the head is marginalised. It is smaller than the circle of flesh revealed by the raised skirt and placed high on the paper. This allows for the vagina to be the initial focal point. The composition is inviting the gaze to rest on her vagina. The image visually constructs the figure鈥檚 desire to be sexually touched and again the viewer is caught by the 鈥楳edusa effect鈥�.
When Gemma Blackshaw says that 鈥楽chiele鈥檚 practice was not 鈥� that of the voyeur, peeking through the curtain, at the woman unawares; rather the female body was represented as continually reacting to that of the artist spectator鈥� she is iterating a related notion.18听The figures on the page act on and react to the viewer, giving desire a visuality. The portrait becomes the visual 鈥榩erformance鈥� of a new un-repression of desire.
Any discussion of repression and expression of desire within Schiele鈥檚 portraits would not be complete without consideration of his repeated representations of the cadaverous or sick. In line with tradition颅al Freudian scholarship Jane Kallir says that this fascination stems from Schiele鈥檚 family history: his father was syphilitic, a disease passed on to his wife who, as a result, suffered a number of stillbirths.19听I should stress that I do not wish to deny or refute such a claim, but I will consider the entanglement of sex, death and life in his work rather than his biography.
In Schiele鈥檚 drawings the focus on death and the disintegration of flesh betrays another step 鈥榖eyond the pleasure principle鈥�, incorporat颅ing a representation of the state of the body once its flesh has begun to decay into pictures of unrepressed desire. Though Freud opposes the sex drive to the death drive, for Jacques Lacan all drives are sex drives and all drives are death drives because every drive is excessive, repetitive and ultimately destructive.20听The death drive is the constant desire in the subject to break through the pleasure principle to achieve excess听箩辞耻颈蝉颅蝉补苍肠别;听jouissance听becomes the path to death and insofar as every drive is an attempt to reach听jouissance听every drive must be a death drive. In this respect, the combining of the two drives in Schiele鈥檚 figures brings them closer to a Lacanian model of the psychical drives.
Kathryn Simpson writes about听Self portrait in Black Cloak Masturbating听(Fig. 6, 1911), 鈥楽chiele pictures himself doomed by Eros and Thanatos together, coiled tightly like a snake about to execute a lethal strike 鈥� where he appears as some kind of neutered vampire鈥�.21听Setting aside the idea that this 鈥榠s鈥� the artist, and considering that the ultimate goal of the subject is, according to Freud, the unity of the body with both Eros and Thanatos, can we really see this figure as doomed? Rather, is this not a representation of the听jouissance听brought about through the death and sexual drives? The pale, mottled greens, ochre and grey of the flesh come together with the less translucent tones of the genital area between his hands. The movement in this work seems to compress the figure. The curve of the head into the body on the left and the oval brush work on the stomach that creates the sensation of the spine sink颅ing both enhance the tension of the body, which can be seen teetering on the edge of dual release 鈥� the pleasure of death and the听un辫濒别补蝉耻谤别听of听jouissance. Eros and Thanatos are encrypted and un-concealed in paint, leaving iconographic traces on the figure on the paper.
滨苍听贰谤辞蝉听(Fig. 5) the fusion of the two drives is iconographically more pronounced. The face has become more skull-like 鈥� Schiele鈥檚 distinctively pointed nose has lost its cartilage and all that remains are the holes in the bone, thinly veiled in greying skin 鈥� a听memento mori听made man. The flesh is closer to decomposition; the light wash gives the impression of it disintegrating into the background, the hand and cloak becoming almost indistinguishable 鈥� flesh becoming inorganic matter. The legs 鈥� which, as with the truncation in听Male Nude Seated听(Fig.1), can be seen as extensions from the phallus rather than a 鈥榗astra颅tion鈥� of the subject 鈥� and the lining of the cloak seem to intertwine. In this picture of decomposition the bright orangey pink of the phallus draws the viewer鈥檚 gaze. Because this is such a clear focal point, the rest of the work is relegated to the role of a frame for the visually encoded sexual drive. The more powerful death drive is balanced by the physical and visual prominence of the Eros drive lauded by the piece鈥檚 title. As with听Black Haired Girl with Raised Skirt听(Fig. 4),听the framing within the work traps the viewer and invites the gaze to 鈥榯ouch鈥� the figure鈥檚 genitals: once again the viewer is caught between the figure鈥檚 desire to 鈥榩aralyse鈥� the beholder, and the figure鈥檚 desire to spur him or her into movement. Both drives thus combine in an image of jouissance and decomposition, a complicated depiction of a dual pictorial desire.
Schiele鈥檚 drawings are figures who give visuality to sexual desire. In answering the question 鈥榳hat do these pictures really want?鈥� there is no need for recourse to the personal history of the artist. In these instances the viewers are caught up by what we may term the 鈥榮ubjectiv颅ity鈥� of the painted figure, their gaze is brought into a sexual game. The figures want satisfaction and ask for it openly through the composition of their bodies and iconographic encryptions of abandon, pleasure and pain. This visualisation of these desires separated these drawings from a society whose stability depended on repression. Though we might use Freud to understand Schiele himself, to confuse the works and the artist is to ask more of the viewer than even Mitchell dares. Similarly, Comini鈥檚 statement that Schiele sought to portray 鈥榩sychological man鈥� oversteps the mark. However, it is possible to argue that elements that were also found in Freud鈥檚 model for the 鈥榩syche鈥� are captured icono颅graphically in paint. Taken beyond the psychological confines of their creator, these works could be used more freely in examinations of fin-de-si猫cle Viennese culture, ideas on sexuality, or gender roles to name but a few possibilities.
With these first thoughts in mind, I would like to address a different aspect of Mitchell鈥檚 essay 鈥� the idea that pictures want equal rights with language but not to be turned into language. However, pre颅viously in his 鈥榯hought experiment鈥� he had come to the conclusion that the 鈥榩icture as subaltern makes an appeal or issues a command whose precise effect and power emerge in an intersubjective encounter com颅pounded of signs of positive desire and traces of lack or impotence鈥�.22听The Oxford English Dictionary, under its entry for 鈥榣anguage鈥� includes the definition 鈥榓 style or method of expression in a non-verbal artistic medium such as music, dance, or the visual arts鈥�.23听By ascribing sub颅jectivity to the picture Mitchell also ascribes them with the power of expression, a language of sorts, in his case made up of 鈥榮igns鈥� and 鈥榯races鈥�. I wish to extend my own 鈥榯hought experiment鈥� to demonstrate that, though there will always be parts of a picture that defy comprehension or translation, there are integral visual elements of 鈥榣anguage鈥� that allow us to ascribe a kind of 鈥榮ubjectivity鈥� to the image.
To do so, I will not turn to Structuralism, which has been widely deployed in twentieth-century art analysis, but to a further channel of thought that emerged in Vienna at the turn of the century 鈥� the听厂辫谤补肠丑办谤颈蝉别听and a new philosophy of language. As a product of the same intellectual and cultural climate, I believe that this a more appro颅priate ground for my exploration. The听厂辫谤补肠丑办谤颈蝉别听first began to appear in cultural and linguistic theory in the last decades of the nineteenth century, and centred on the idea that language could no longer be used adequately to describe abstract concepts or the nature of the world. Friedrich Nietzsche encapsulated the beginning of this crisis of faith in 1878: 鈥業t is only now that it is dawning on man that he has propa颅gated an enormous error with his belief in language鈥�.24听In 1902 Hugo von Hofmannsthal took this idea further in the 鈥楲ord Chandos Letter鈥�, which detailed the gradual loss of trust in language, starting with words such as 鈥榮pirit鈥�, 鈥榮oul鈥� and 鈥榖ody鈥�. The arbitrary connection of the word to the object became an insurmountable problem, and the body became the focus of much discussion of this issue as the place in which the individual and the linguistic universals converged.25
Michael Hunter suggests this emphasis on the body can be seen as Vienna鈥檚 desire to communicate 鈥榳hat is too big, too general, too close to be expressed in words鈥�.26听The younger generation of writers and art颅ists became obsessed with a language and an aesthetic that had a strict claim to authenticity 鈥� they wanted a marriage of fact and expression. This endeavour affected Schiele鈥檚 practice, as well as that of contem颅poraries such as Oskar Kokoschka.27听In the same way that they can be seen to visually project elements of sexual desire closely connected to contemporary psychoanalytic channels of enquiry, Schiele鈥檚 portraits arguably contain a system of pictorial signs analogous to the 鈥榣ogical lan颅guage鈥� posited by Wittgenstein in the听Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus,听which, though published in 1921, was first conceived of and drafted in 1913.
Wittgenstein was concerned with the conditions that would have to be fulfilled by a logically perfect language. He was aware that such a language was a technical impossibility, but the nature of language is such that it only fulfills its purpose of conveying meaning insofar as it approximates to the ideal language postulated. Essentially, he believed that the function of language was to assert or deny facts. The first req颅uisite of such a language was that there should be one name for every 鈥榮imple鈥� object. The name would be the symbol for the object in lan颅guage. A name was a 鈥榮imple鈥� symbol because it could not be reduced further. When something is not a simple Wittgenstein termed it a whole or 鈥榗omplex鈥�, which contained the symbols for the constituent parts. In the material world a complex is a fact. He defined two types of fact: a non-compound fact was known as a听Sachverhalt听or 鈥榓tomic fact鈥�, and a compound fact was known as a听Tatsache.听The example used in Bertrand Russell鈥檚 introduction to the text is that of 鈥楽ocrates was a wise Athenian鈥�. This contains the facts 鈥楽ocrates was wise鈥� and 鈥楽ocrates was an Athenian鈥� and is, therefore, a听Tatsache.听The fact 鈥楽ocrates was wise鈥� is an atomic fact or听Sachverhalt,听though it is still a complex rather than a simple as it contains the different symbols, 鈥楽ocrates鈥� and 鈥榳ise鈥�.28听Schiele鈥檚 portraits and the subjectivity they develop can be expressed within the tenets of Wittgenstein鈥檚 general premise. The desires expressed can be broken down and thought of as the 鈥榝acts鈥� of the figures, underlining the nature of what they really want.
Let us return to听Black Haired Girl with Raised Skirt听(Fig. 4) and deconstruct our previous visual analysis of the figure鈥檚 desires along Wittgenstein鈥檚 lines. As was observed, there is a broad circle of blue-black paint that surrounds a small, deep pink area. We can translate these two images into the sentence 鈥榯he skirt frames the vagina鈥� (this is not to claim that the image and the word are interchangeable, but for the purpose of thinking about the image as a form of language such a translation is necessary). For Wittgenstein this would be an 鈥榓tomic fact鈥�, on the paper it is the unalterable composition of these two components of the image. We can create further 鈥榓tomic facts鈥�: the hair frames her face; the skirt mirrors the colour and shape of the hair; the lip colour matches the labia colour. All of these are unalterable parts of the image.
When we ask 鈥榳hat does the image want鈥� these are the 鈥榝acts鈥� that enter into the response. As Wittgenstein did with language, the viewer has to break down the images to their component parts, into the indisputable elements before they can go beyond the surface of the paper and postulate a response to the question. Only once this has occurred can the viewer move into the realm that Mitchell saw as a 鈥榮uspension of disbelief 鈥�, or Wittgenstein would have termed an impos颅sibility 鈥� the point at which these elements are ascribed a further mean颅ing, a subjective meaning. In this respect Mitchell and Wittgenstein were proposing very similar 鈥榯hought experiments鈥� to their audience: a technically impossible move from objecthood to subjectivity.
We can begin to see 鈥榯he skirt frames the vagina鈥� as an indica颅tion of sexual desire because of our knowledge of other facts in the world, such as 鈥楤oticelli鈥檚 Venus hides her vagina鈥�, and facts specific to the image, such as 鈥榯he viewer鈥檚 gaze rests on the vagina鈥�. We build up the 鈥榯ruth鈥� of what the image wants by performing an act very close to Wittgenstein鈥檚 linguistic analysis. By comparing and contrasting various 鈥榝acts鈥� we come to the conclusion that Schiele鈥檚 images are asking some颅thing different of the viewer to other nudes. This is the body 鈥榮howing鈥� its sexual desire. Such a process is only possible if we consider that the image has a semiotic function of its own. In his analysis of what pic颅tures want Mitchell implicitly accepts this whilst explicitly denying it.
Experimenting with visual 鈥榝acts鈥� can be extended further to compare versions of sexual desire displayed by different images. For example, in听Black Haired Girl Nude Standing听(Fig. 2) the carefully spaced use of rose pink creates a rhomboid between the mouth, nipples and vagina. Wittgenstein uses the geometric shape as a visual metaphor for the simple as it exists in different languages 鈥� it can be projected in many different ways, but its inherent properties will always remain the same. The shape in the image guides the viewer鈥檚 gaze over the body; moving from the objecthood to subjectivity we can say that the image 鈥榳ants鈥� to be touched by the beholder. Schiele鈥檚 use of white heightening around the girl鈥檚 outline further delineates the figure from the background. This is in line with Wittgenstein鈥檚 proposition that 鈥榓 spatial object must be situated in infinite space鈥�.29听The absence of all extraneous material in the watercolour focuses the viewer on the 鈥榝acts鈥� of the body and its desires.
滨苍听Nude Girls Reclining听(Fig. 7, 1911) the lower figure contains the same rhomboid configuration seen in听Black-Haired Nude Girl Standing,听with the pink detail on the pubic bone, the nipples and the mouth. However, in听Nude Girls Reclining听a second rhomboid can be seen, created by the lower nipple of the prone girl, the visible nipple of the propped-up figure and their two mouths. A comparison of the differ颅ent rhomboids in the two pictures opens up our questioning into want the pictures want. Where one rhomboid appears the image鈥檚 subjective sexual desire is projected out at the viewer. Where two rhomboids inter颅act on the paper the relationship is more complex. Are these rhomboids inviting the viewer鈥檚 gaze to roam over their bodies as an active com颅ponent in the visual game, or are they depicting a mutual desire for one another that the viewer witnesses passively?
In the dialogue between the images and between image and viewer we start to build up an understanding of what the images might want. In the case of Schiele鈥檚 nudes this is, for the most part, sexual desire. In fin-de-si猫cle Vienna this was a complex notion. Schiele鈥檚 arrest for public indecency in 1912 indicates that his contemporaries, like so many art historians of more recent years, felt that the images were a reflection of the artist鈥檚 character or psyche. However, attempts to psychoanalyse Schiele through his works will always be problematic. This thought experiment has attempted to move away from this and to open up Schiele鈥檚 works to a new avenue of exploration. By taking these works beyond the psychological confines of their creator they can begin to play a much more interesting part in a consideration of sexuality in fin-de-si猫cle Vienna than might otherwise be the case. They become part of the wider dialogue surrounding the breakdown of the faultless fa莽ade of Viennese society.
Citations
- Jane Kallir,听Egon Schiele Life and Work听(New York: Harry Abrams, 2003), 127鈥�149.
- Alessandra Comini,听Egon Schiele鈥檚 Portraits听(Berkeley: University of California Press, 1990), 1鈥�2.
- W. T. J Mitchell, 鈥榃hat do Pictures Really Want?鈥�, October, 77 (1996), 71鈥�82.
- Mitchell, 82. 5. Stefan Zweig,听Die Welt von Gestern听(Frankfurt: S. Fischer Verlag, 1970), 78.
- Carl Schorske,听Fin de Si猫cle Vienna: Politics and Culture听(London: Weidenfeld and Nicholson, 1980), xx鈥搙xv.
- Sigmund Freud, 鈥楾he Ego and the Id鈥� (1923), in James Strachey ed.,听The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, 24 vols, vol. 19 (London: The Hogarth Press, 1995), 13.
- Mitchell, 76.
- Freud (1923), 17鈥�19.
- Freud (1923), 24.
- Freud (1923), 20鈥�22.
- See also Sigmund Freud, 鈥楾hree Essays on the Theory of Sexuality鈥� (1905) and 鈥楤eyond the Pleasure Principle鈥� (1920) in Strachey, vol. 7, 207鈥�222; vol. 18, 7鈥�64.
- Arthur Roessler,听Egon Schiele im Gef盲ngnis: Aufzeichnungen und Zeichnungen听(Vienna: Carl Konegan, 1922), 33.
- See for example Comini; Wolfgang Fischer,听Egon Schiele: Desire and Decay听(K枚ln: Taschen, 1995); Kathryn Simpson, 鈥楧ionysian Ugliness and Radical Beauty in Egon Schiele鈥檚 Oeuvre鈥� in Peter Vergo and Barnaby Wright eds.,听Egon Schiele: The Radical Nude听(London: Paul Holberton Publishing, 2014), 50鈥�65.
- Freud (1920), 36鈥�45.
- Freud (1920), 21.
- Laura Mulvey, 鈥榁isual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema鈥�, in Amelia Jones ed.,听The Feminism and Visual Culture Reader听(Routledge: London, 2003), 44鈥�52; Griselda Pollock,听Avant-Garde Gambits, 1888-1893: Gender and the Colour of Art History听(London: Thames and Hudson, 1992), 7鈥�9.
- Gemma Blackshaw, 鈥楾he Modernist Offence: Schiele and the Naked Female Body鈥�, in Peter Vergo and Barnaby Wright eds.,听Egon Schiele: The Radical Nude听(London: Paul Holberton Publishing, 2014), 31鈥�49, 38.
- Kallir, 136.
- Dylan Evans,听An Introductory Dictionary of Lacanian Psychoanalysis听(New York: Brunner-Routledge, 1996), 32鈥�91.
- Simpson, 56.
- Mitchell, 79.
- 鈥榣anguage, n. (and int.)鈥�,听OED Online听(Published n.d., Accessed 25/9/2016, http:// www.oed.com/view/Entry/105582?rskey= rkQMQv&result=1&isAdvanced=false#eid).
- Friedrich Nietzsche, 鈥楧ie Sprache als ver颅meintliche Wissenschaft鈥�, in Karl Schlechta ed.,听Friedrich Nietzsche: Werke in drei B盲nden: Band 1听(Munich: Carl Hanser Verlag, 1954), 453.
- Hugo von Hofmannsthal,听Der Brief des Lord Chandos: Schriften zur Literatur, Kunst und Geschichte, Mathias Mayer ed. (Stuttgart: Reclam Verlag, 2000), 18-21.
- Hugo von Hofmannsthal, 鈥楨ssay on Mime鈥�, in Michael Hunter, 鈥楤ody as Metaphor: Aspects of the Critique and Crisis of Language at the Turn of the Century with Reference to Schiele鈥� in Patrick Werkner ed.,听Egon Schiele: Art, Sexuality and Viennese Modernism听(Seattle: University of Washington Press, 1994), 119鈥�129, 125.
- Ferdinand Opll and Peter Csendes eds.,听Wien: Die Geschichte einer Stadt, Band 3:Von 1790 bis zur Gegenwart.听(Vienna: B枚hlau, 2006), 269.
- Bertrand Russell, introduction to Ludwig Wittgenstein,听Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus,听David Pears and Brian McGuiness trans. (Abingdon: Routledge Classics, 1974), ix鈥� xxiv.
- Ludwig Wittgenstein,听Tractatus Logico- Philosophicus,听David Pears and Brian McGuiness trans. (Abingdon: Routledge Classics, 1974), 6.
- Ludwig Wittgenstein,听Tractatus Logico- Philosophicus,听David Pears and Brian McGuiness trans. (Abingdon: Routledge Classics, 1974), 6.